LED VS HPS  

 

Sammy
(@sammy)
Getting Comfortable Forum Member
100 Likes
Points:431
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 36
September 19, 2019 9:00 am  

Big Shout out @percysgrowroom an fellow subscribers!! just wanted to hear people’s thoughts on what they like best and why? Much love 👍🏻🇬🇧


Quote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 19, 2019 9:28 am  

Not an easy subject to cover tbf 😉

Depends on your situation, but for me, HPS is king for flowering. Quantum board are awesome but too expensive. HPS is cheap and easy, you have to know more about how light works if you want to grow LED 

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


Sammy
(@sammy)
Getting Comfortable Forum Member
100 Likes
Points:431
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 36
September 19, 2019 9:32 am  

@macky

Nice one mate, I’ve always done hps veg/flower just wanted to know how many agree lol 👍🏻🇬🇧


ReplyQuote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 19, 2019 9:39 am  

Well, Metal Halide is better for veg, as it has the blue light spectrum the plants prefer, the switch to HPS when flowers start forming. Or you can use dual spectrums the whole way. 

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


ReplyQuote
Ivean420
(@ivean420)
Regular Known User
100 Likes
250 Likes
100 Posts
Points:1291
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 109
September 19, 2019 9:47 am  

100% led for me.

I run low watts for veg. Around 90w in a 80x80x160 tent.

450w in my main tent 1.2x1.2x1.8

I use 3500k cobs and grow autos 90% of the time. 

All my cobs can be dimmed down to 10% and I love the flexibility 

Using some more single cobs at 60w each if I ever need to add more.

My main reason was heat,electric cost and coverage. 

I find it much easier to grow with multiple lights than a big fuck off bulb.

 


ReplyQuote
Sammy
(@sammy)
Getting Comfortable Forum Member
100 Likes
Points:431
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 36
September 19, 2019 9:53 am  

@ivean420

Nice one mate bet you grow some lovely stuff! I’m liking the cobs 👍🏻


ReplyQuote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 19, 2019 10:01 am  

Don't get me wrong, I use HPS, CMH and LED lights, Its just them good LEDs cost a lot of money on the initial set up. I wanna build my own QB, but waiting for Ivan to write a guide 😉 

I think, QBs will rule one day, but HPS is just well known and reliable. You know you're gonna get good flowers with it. 

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


ReplyQuote
Ivean420
(@ivean420)
Regular Known User
100 Likes
250 Likes
100 Posts
Points:1291
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 109
September 19, 2019 11:19 am  

@macky

I'm yet to try some qb's and tbh I dont really see any benefit over the cobs.

Only reason I think I'd change now was if I was having height issues. Qb's seem to be great if have a small space. 

Qbs can also run a bit cooler than cobs but being in the uk I need more heat from my lights during the colder months or I have to add heating which defeats the object of keeping leccy costs down.

In my 1.2 tent I run 8 autos under 450w and get a minimum of 1.2 gpw 

I think the lowest I've had is around 2oz per plant but I have hit around 1.7 gpw and they average out at around 2.5/3 oz per plant. 

My very first grow I used 2x 400w hps and they just didnt have the spread I wanted so swapped them for cobs and dont think I'll ever go back.

Before I purchased the cobs I priced up moving over to cmh but with all the parts needed and the new bulbs etc every 12-18 months the cobs were much more cost effective and I took 300w of light away 🙂 


ReplyQuote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 19, 2019 12:46 pm  

im yet to try either man lol. I've not done cobs or QBS, either one looks good. 

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


ReplyQuote
TempleGrower
(@templegrower)
Manic Organic
100 Likes
Diary Writer
500 Likes
100 Posts
250 Likes
1K Likes
250 Posts
Points:4020
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 383
September 20, 2019 1:19 am  

Yep, IMO, the best LEDs are better than the best HIDs, but the best HIDs cost WAY less than the best LEDs, initially... so it's a cost/benefit thing I think...depending on your situation. I've run mid-grade versions of both... flower from my LED seemed a bit denser/tighter/more fragrant, but the HPS plants were bigger and more yieldy.... so I dunno. LoL. Hard question... replacing bulbs does suck though... 😉 

Life's a garden...dig it - Joe Dirt


ScottishMac, Ivean420, Macky and 1 people liked
ReplyQuote
Fukentokin
(@fukentokin)
Percy Grower
Diary Writer
100 Likes
100 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
Points:2642
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 218
September 20, 2019 5:47 am  

Ive had this discussion lots over the past two months and quite frankly, lights are specific to the grower. Both HID and LED have pros and cons.  Is a painter or a sculptor  the better artist?

Its all about PAR. Scientists are involved now so we have leds that can hit the specific nanometers required for chlorophyll a and b to flourish in between 400-700 nanometer PAR. HID hit those nanometers in shear penetration. They measure this in umols( micromol). One umol is equivalent to 602 quadrillion photons of light. For example: An illuminare Il8 8 bar led fixture puts out 600 u mols compared to a 1000w phillips hps bulb doing 484 umols both measured from 6”. Both will flower great. One costs twice as much. One you don’t need to switch bulbs every nine months. Yadda yadda back and forth. 

I personally use both. It’s all about bringing outside to the inside and creating a perfect balance between all of your equipment so we can emulate nature as best we can. I’ve heard all the same arguments from both sides and imo one is not better than the other, your the artist, you decide what works best for you. 

It is better to keep one’s mouth shut and let everyone think You’re a fool than to open it and prove them all right


ScottishMac, Ivean420, Macky and 1 people liked
ReplyQuote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 20, 2019 10:14 am  
Posted by: @fukentokin

Is a painter or a sculptor  the better artist

This is exactly it man lol. we all have different situations we are growing in, and we all use whats best for us. There is no right or wrong answer as long as the plants stay happy 🙂

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


Fukentokin, ScottishMac, Zombie Nation and 1 people liked
ReplyQuote
Ivean420
(@ivean420)
Regular Known User
100 Likes
250 Likes
100 Posts
Points:1291
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 109
September 20, 2019 12:01 pm  

Totally agree but........

My main issue is power consumption. We are unfortunately forced to grow indoors under artificial light. The amount of power that people who grow weed use is way to much.

Even with my leds I hit 1kw per hour with all my fans,extractor etc

That's not sustainable for the planet 🙁 

When I was using hid lighting I was hitting nearly 2kw per hour. I needed more extraction in the summer months etc. 

Power consumption was my deciding factor and if it cost me a few hundred to build a lower wattage light then imo it's worth it for the lower consumption:)


ReplyQuote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 20, 2019 12:04 pm  
Posted by: @ivean420

That's not sustainable for the planet 🙁

Agree 100% man, I d go for lower wattage lights and get less yield, I have issues with that, just that initial setup cost kills it lol I Love QBs, but I can't afford one right now 🙁 But if I had a choice, I wouldn't be growing with HPS, Id go QBs for sure. right now i use 315 CMH, not using the Hps at all 🙂 But winter approaches, gonna need the heat then lol

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


ReplyQuote
Ivean420
(@ivean420)
Regular Known User
100 Likes
250 Likes
100 Posts
Points:1291
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 109
September 20, 2019 12:15 pm  

It's not as expensive as you think to start with 🙂

1 x https://www.tme.eu/gb/details/rad-a52317_1000/radiators/stonecold/

1 x https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.co.uk%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F222462989764

 

1x

10x IDEAL Solderless Holders for CITIZEN COB CLU048 50-2204CT | eBay

Then about £10 on a dimmer some wire and a plug 🙂 

 


ReplyQuote
Macky
(@macky)
Part of the Furniture Admin
Mentor
100 Posts
250 Posts
500 Posts
1K Posts
100 Likes
2500 Posts
250 Likes
500 Likes
1K Likes
2.5K Likes
5K Likes
Points:35159
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 3764
September 20, 2019 12:26 pm  

I aint got time for that man 😉 have to buy mine set up already looking at £500 ish for the light i want 

"True guidance is like a torch in the forest, it doesn't show everything, but gives enough light for the next steps to be safe" -Swami Vivekananda


ReplyQuote
Share:

We have guides to growing cannabis, cannabis grow dairies that cover growing weed in hydroponics, soil and coco. Find the help you need, by either, using the search box, or asking for help in the forum.

Our cannabis growers website also has competitions where you can win free weed seeds. As a member you will also have discount codes for cannabis seeds, and LED grow Lighting.
Our Cannabis Growers Forum is for educational purposes and we encourage our members to check their country of residence legislation before germinating a marijuana seed.

This site is here because we want to help you grow your own cannabis for personal use. Therefore, any member who is suspected of growing cannabis for commercial gains will be banned immediately.

Please read our forum rules, and enjoy the site.

Percys Grow Room Facebook Page, Cannabis grower forum fb page,
Percys Grow Room Twitter,
Percys Grow Room Instagram

Find us on all social networks! Just search for Percys Grow Room

Please Login or Register